| Rating |
Game |
Div |
Referee |
Convenor |
Comments |
| 4 |
25090705 |
B |
Oktay Selcuk |
Phil Prata |
Good control of game despite a lot of chirping. Rescinded a red card on advice from both convenors showing respect for the convenors which is commendable and unusual in a ref. Great start as a BOTSC ref. |
| 1 |
25090702 |
A |
Chris Lynch |
Michael Ogilvie |
He got many calls wrong - he didn’t call an obvious red card, many offsides, two handballs, and he called three soft non-fouls. The fouls were so soft even the player (supposedly) fouled was surprised. |
| 5 |
25081704 |
B |
Len West |
Phil Prata |
As usual great communication on all decisions. |
| 5 |
25081003 |
B |
Phil Fiorillo |
Rick Mignano |
Very good referee. |
| 3 |
25072706 |
B |
Duncan Taylor |
Phil Prata |
Kept control of the game. Far too aggressive when speaking to players, which leaves many feeling they do not trust the ref. to make fair calls. |
| 5 |
25072003 |
B |
Ronnie Stevenson |
Robert Dean |
Nothing controversial happened. No impactful calls needed. |
| 1 |
25072002 |
B |
Chris Lynch |
Phil Prata |
Too many stoppages for unnecessary lectures to convenors and players. Ridiculous attitude towards a player who stepped off the field temporarily to avoid influencing the play in an offside position.
Too often the ref wanted to be the centre of attention. Players don't want to hire refs that think they are more important than the game. |
| 1 |
25060805 |
B |
Ronnie Stevenson |
Phil Prata |
Far too often distant from the play. Communication with players / convenors is non-existent. Played a 51 minute 2nd half when both teams had no subs. Gave 2 penalties, where neither was an attempt to play the ball, yet gave no cards. |
| 2 |
25060805 |
B |
Ronnie Stevenson |
Rick Mignano |
Misses too many crucial fouls |
| 5 |
25060802 |
A |
Peter Bekker |
Michael Ogilvie |
|
| 5 |
25060106 |
A |
Mitch Master |
Neri Ciraku |
|
| 4 |
25060106 |
A |
Len West |
Michael Ogilvie |
No issues. He was in control of the game from start to finish. |
| 4 |
25060105 |
A |
Terry McColl |
Rick Moretuzzo |
|
| 4 |
25060104 |
A |
Dorin Dragusanu |
Frank Casale |
|
| 4 |
25060104 |
A |
Dorin Dragusanu |
Frank Mills |
|
| 4 |
25060103 |
B |
Chris Lynch |
Martin Wilson |
He kept control of the game and let the game flow- as best Chris can... |
| 5 |
25060103 |
B |
Chris Lynch |
Rick Mignano |
|
| 5 |
25060102 |
B |
Terry McColl |
Phil Prata |
Game under control at all times. |
| 4 |
25060102 |
B |
Terry McColl |
Robert Dean |
Let a few too many “rough plays” go, for my liking in an over 60 division. Calling a few early in the game would send a message. |
| 4 |
25060101 |
B |
Phil Fiorillo |
Frank Rosati |
|
| 3 |
25060101 |
B |
Phil Fiorillo |
Brian McLaughlin |
|
| 4 |
25052505 |
B |
Ronnie Stevenson |
Robert Dean |
Touch line calls, offside calls, seemed to be made by whichever team complained the most |
| 5 |
25052504 |
B |
Phil Fiorillo |
Phil Prata |
Up with play and dealt with player claims clearly and firmly. Rarely noticed him during the game. |
| 5 |
25052503 |
A |
Peter Bekker |
Michael Ogilvie |
|
| 5 |
25052503 |
A |
Peter Bekker |
Gerard Kelly |
|
| 3 |
25052501 |
A |
Dorin Dragusanu |
Frank Mills |
Dorin is such nice man he made few mistakes but all and all nice job |
| 5 |
25051806 |
A |
Mitch Master |
Frank Casale |
|
| 5 |
25051806 |
A |
Mitch Master |
Frank Mills |
Has been ref for our last 2 games and has been great good job Mitch |
| 4 |
25051806 |
A |
Mitch Master |
Michael Ogilvie |
Good.
Mitch could’ve made a couple PK calls - one handball, and another a foul. More subjective calls vs bad calls. |
| 3 |
25051805 |
A |
Phil Fiorillo |
Rick Moretuzzo |
Did a good job controlling the game - Made the right call the majority of the time. |
| 5 |
25051805 |
A |
Phil Fiorillo |
Neri Ciraku |
|
| 1 |
25051803 |
B |
Ronnie Stevenson |
Martin Wilson |
Can't keep up with the game and poor decisions. This was the second game in a row and same poor performance. |
| 5 |
25051802 |
B |
Len West |
Phil Prata |
Great calls, always up with play, never inserted himself into the game. |
| 5 |
25051801 |
B |
Chris Lynch |
Robert Dean |
|
|
| Number of Reviews = 34 , Average Rating = 3.9 |
